Why is Sally a phony?
Holden’s insulting words towards Sally tell us a lot more about him than they do about her. She represents everything he’s come to despise. She’s bubbly, popular, and entirely at ease with the society in which she moves so effortlessly. This makes her a “phony” in Holden’s eyes.
Why does Holden cry at the carousel?
Holden is struggling to find his place in the world, and there are so many people that disappoint him. He could also be crying because he is disappointed to himself…but once again, Phoebe’s acceptance of him despite his “disappointing behaviors” may simply be too great a joy to endure without tears.
What is Holden desperate for?
Holden is desperate for authenticity. He expresses his frustration with phony people and their phony behaviors throughout the entirety of the novel. Holden’s sister Phoebe is special to him because she isn’t phony at all, and perhaps it is her youth that prevents her from being this way.
What is the only class Holden is not failing?
What is the only class he passed? He failed four out of five subjects. The only class he passed was English. Why is Holden watching the football game at the beginning of the novel?
Why is Holden happy at the end?
Chapter 25 concludes with Holden feeling happy as he watches Phoebe ride on the Central Park carousel. One possible reading would take Holden at his word. This would entail believing that his happiness at the end of Chapter 25 is genuine and that this happiness predicts an eventual, full recovery.
Why does Holden call Carl?
In Chapter Nineteen, Holden admits that the main reason he called his childhood friend Carl Luce, besides wanting some company, is that old Luce was always good for a sex talk. Apparently, all he did at the Whooton school as a student adviser was “give these sex talks …
Why did Holden have to leave Ernie’s?
Why does Holden leave Ernie’s? Holden leaves Ernie’s because Lillian is becoming annoying. He would rather leave then spend more time talking to her. Holden becomes unimpressed with him and leaves.
How did Holden lose his innocence?
In The Catcher in the Rye, Holden loses his innocence at the age of thirteen, when his brother, Allie, dies of leukemia. He blames himself for not being able to protect his brother and wants to become the catcher in the rye, rescuing children before they can fall off the edge of a cliff.
What is the one thing Holden tells Phoebe he likes?
After remembering the death of this young boy, the only thing Holden can think to tell Phoebe he likes is “Allie.” His mind is increasingly preoccupied with childhood and childhood death; he thinks to call Mr. Antolini when he remembers the teacher picking up James Castle’s broken body in his coat.
What does Carl think Holden needs do you think Carl is right?
Do you think Carl is right? Carl thinks that Holden needs to go to a psychoanalyst, which is Carl’s to get him on his feet, and stop fooling around with his life.
Does Holden ever call Jane?
Holden decides that girls always say that as an excuse to date arrogant boys. Finally, he calls Jane, but no one answers. He then calls a boy named Carl Luce, whom he used to know at the Whooton School, and Luce agrees to meet him for drinks later that night.
How does Carl respond to Holden’s?
He further confesses to Carl on how to start a companionship. He also expressed his sadness on being unable to get sexual with a girls he loves. At this point, Carl does not show any interest nor say anything to tell Holden that he has noble feelings.
Why did Holden call Carl Luce even though he didn’t like him much?
Why did Holden call Carl Luce even though he didn’t like him much? Holden was desperate for a companion with whom to pass the time. He also thought that since Carl Luce was quite intellectual, Luce might be able to help him. They mostly talked about Luce’s romantic life and Holden’s lack of one.
Is Mr Antolini a phony?
Mr. Antolini is the adult who comes closest to reaching Holden. He manages to avoid alienating Holden, and being labeled a “phony,” because he doesn’t behave conventionally.
Is Holden Caulfield mentally ill?
While Salinger never provides a specific diagnosis, references to Holden’s mental instability are clear throughout the novel, and the reader could easily make the connection that Holden suffers from some combination of depression, anxiety, and/or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Why does Holden deny really knowing James?
He admired James’ integrity and courage for standing up for what he believes in. However, Holden denies knowing James because they never really talks in school, all they ever really talked about was James wanting to borrow his turtleneck sweater.
What mental disorder does Holden Caulfield have?
What does Holden say to Sally that makes her angry?
Holden, of course, is aware of the mutability of time. Things will change. The moment will be lost. The disagreement turns angry, and Holden tells Sally that she gives him “a royal pain in the ass.” Suffice to say that, after this remark, the date is over.
Is Holden in a mental hospital?
Holden (despite the confusion of the Harcourt Brace executive) is not crazy; he tells his story from a sanatorium (where he has gone because of a fear that he has t.b.), not a mental hospital.
What made Holden not so depressed?
He got her the “Little Shirley Beans” record. What made Holden “not so depressed anymore” on his way to the record store? The little boy singing as he was walking with his parents.
Why is Holden obsessed with innocence?
In the novel The Catcher in the Rye, Holden is obsessed in preserving his innocence. Due to his obsession of preserving his innocence, he wishes to be “the catcher in the rye” to protect the children from falling off the cliff. He finds the adult world corrupted and poisonous.
How does Holden remember his own childhood?
How does Holden remember his own childhood? Holden thinks about him going to the museum when he was young with his class. Holden’s date is a disaster because he asks her to marry him and run away with him but he really doesn’t love her or even like her that much.
Why did Holden cry in Chapter 23?
Holden is crying when he leaves his home at the end of chapter 23 because he has been crying internally since the beginning of the novel. Holden is obviously looking for something throughout the entire book. He is unhappy because he feels lonely and because he has a bad opinion of himself.
Why did Holden Miss Allie’s funeral?
Holden, distraught over the loss of his brother, broke his hand punching the windows out of the garage of their summer home. Holden missed Allie’s funeral because he was in the hospital, apparently for psychiatric evaluation as well as for attention to his hand. Holden keeps the glove with him and has it at Pencey.
Why does Holden say he loves Sally?
Despite the fact that Sally is obviously not a good match for him, Holden claims that at the moment he proposed that they run away together, he did truly love her. His feelings are irrational, but they indicate how desperate he is to find love.
Who does Holden ask to marry him?
As Holden sways from one plan to escape the restrictions of society to another, he hits upon an excellent (to his mind at least) idea to just run away and live in nature with Sally and get married.
How does Phoebe know Holden got kicked out of school?
Phoebe realized he got kicked out because he was supposed to be home Wednesday. She kept saying his father was going to kill him, she hit him a few times, and stuck her head under the pillow.
Why does Holden enjoy talking to the nuns?
He sees the nuns as innocent, as evidenced by his comment about feeling uncomfortable talking to the nun who happens to be an English teacher about Romeo and Juliet because “that play gets pretty sexy in some parts.” In other parts of the novel, Holden shows charity and kindness toward those who need it.
Does Holden Caulfield lose his virginity?
Holden Caulfield does not lose his virginity during the course of The Catcher in the Rye, though he makes some half-hearted attempts to do so.
What does Carl Luce recommend to Holden?
Carl Luce recommended that Holden go to a psychoanalyst.